Hypertrophic Scar Vs. Keloid: What’s The Difference?

Formation of scars is a natural healing process. When the skin sustains an injury through a cut, burn or other trauma, the body produces a protein known as collagen to facilitate the healing process in the damaged area. 

When the body generates excessive scar tissue, the scar tissues become raised, thick and vividly noticeable. The two types of raised scars are clinically referred to as keloid and hypertrophic scars.  

Let’s walk you through this blog to help you understand how keloids and hypertrophic scars differ in how they grow, where they appear and how they behave over time. 

What Is A Hypertrophic Scar?

A hypertrophic scar is a raised scar that remains within the boundaries of the original wound or injury. Unlike keloids, hypertrophic scars often develop relatively soon after an injury and are more common in areas of the body where your skin is taut, such as your back, chest, shoulders and upper arms, elbows and other joints. However, these scars can occur anywhere on the skin where there has been an injury or a wound. 

What Are Keloids?

The thick, raised overgrowths of scar tissue that grow past the edges of the original skin injury are known as keloids. Keloid is a dermo-fibroproliferative disorder thought to result from abnormal proliferation of fibroblasts. 

The scar tissue extends into the surrounding healthy skin instead of staying within the skin area that was injured. A keloid most often occurs after an ear piercing, acne, an injection, a cut, or a surgical incision. 

Keloids have the tendency to become significantly larger than the original wound and can continue to grow for months or even years. Keloids feel itchy, tender, painful, or uncomfortable, particularly when they continue to grow.

Also Read: Arm Lift Surgery: Who Benefits From Brachioplasty

What’s The Difference Between Hypertrophic Scars And Keloid Scars?

To understand the difference between a keloid and a hypertrophic scar, we need to look at how the scar behaves in relation to the original wound. 

Feature  Hypertrophic Scars Keloid Scars  
Causes  Get triggered by deep injuries like burns or wounds under high skin tension. Get triggered by deep injuries like burns or wounds under high skin tension. Additionally, triggered by genetic predisposition. 
Natural Course May gradually flatten, soften, and fade over time.  Rarely go away on their own and tend to enlarge continuously. 
Time to develop Appear quickly within weeks or months after injury.  Develop slowly over months or even years. 
Growth Boundary  Stay within the limits of the original wound.  Spread and grow beyond the original wound edges into the healthy skin. 

Not every raised scar follows the textbook pattern. A qualified plastic surgeon can accurately assess the scar based on its appearance, history, location and progression.

Why Does The Difference Matter?

The difference influences how the scar will be managed. 

A hypertrophy most often becomes less noticeable gradually. On the contrary, keloid scars persist and require treatment to reduce their size, symptoms or appearance.

Medical intervention is required when a scar causes itching, pain, restricted movement or significant cosmetic concern.

How Are Hypertrophic Scars And Keloid Scars Treated? 

The first line of treatment for keloids and hypertrophic scars is primarily through a combination of intralesional steroid (corticosteroid) injections, silicone gel sheets, and compression therapy, based on the size and nature of the scar.

While hypertrophic scars have the tendency to confine themselves to the original wound site and heal naturally in a short span of time, keloids extend beyond the wound area and need  aggressive multimodal management.  

Non-Surgical Treatment Options. 

  • Silicone Gel: For treating the scars, silicone gel sheets are recommended to be worn for up to 23 hours a day over a period of certain months as prescribed by the plastic surgeon to flatten and soften the tissue. 
  • Pressure Therapy: A pressure garment is applied to the scar region for a period of 6 to 24 months to lessen the collagen production and improve the appearance of the scar. 
  • Laser Therapy: Pulsed-dye lasers (PDL) or Nd:YAG lasers target blood vessels in the scar to reduce redness, itching, and hardness 
  • Corticosteroid Injections: Triamcinolone is injected directly into the scar every few weeks to reduce inflammation and break down collagen, effectively flattening raised tissue 
  • Antimetabolite Injections: Medications like 5-Fluorouracil (5-FU) are often combined with steroids to shrink stubborn scars with fewer side effects.

Surgical Treatment Options: 

Cutting out the scar is considered necessary for large or treatment-resistant lesions. Surgery is almost always combined with adjuvant therapy such as superficial radiation therapy or steroid injections. Adjuvant therapy is done to prevent severe scars, especially keloids, from returning. 

When Should You Seek Evaluation For a Raised Scar?

Professional evaluation by a qualified plastic surgeon is essential if the scar:

  • Persists to grow
  • Is painful or perpetually itchy
  • Hinders your movement
  • Has drastic changes in colour or texture
  • Takes a toll on your self-confidence
  • Persists without any noticeable improvement

Also Read: Thigh Lift Surgery: When Is It Recommended?

Note From Viva Esthetique:

Scars may be persistent – but with the right strategy, they are indeed manageable. At Viva Esthetique, we combine cutting-edge technology  with patient-focused care to help you feel comfortable in your skin again. 

If the scar continues to grow and becomes uncomfortable or it affects your self-confidence, getting it examined is important. A thorough assessment can help determine what type of scar you have and what treatments you can opt for. 

Whether it’s a new bump or a long-standing scar, we’re ready to help you manage it right. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top